A NYT Article About Haiti Is Further Proof That Black History Only Matters When White People Tell It – Yahoo News

Recently, I got a barrage of the same text message. The New York Times wrote about Haiti and it was important — because The New York Times wrote about it.
The Times published a lengthy article about the history of Haiti and its interaction (read: abuse) with the rest of the world on May 20, 2022. The article was long and interesting; It was well-researched. It was thoughtful, it was objective and it was careful.
It was also not new.
The article itself discusses the double debt and ransom placed upon post-colonial Haiti after their victory of freedom over the French. It covers Haiti’s dictators, the occupation by the United States and the democratic election of Jean Bertrand Aristide.
One of the authors, Catherine Porter, appeared on The Daily where she further explored the research and answered any questions that may have been lingering.
During her appearance on The Daily, one of the quotes that stood out the most is what she had to say about when you ask “people” about Haiti’s poverty.
“The answer you normally get when you ask people this deeper ‘why’ is corruption.” Porter asserts.
I wonder if the people Ms. Porter was referring to included Haitians. I’m almost certain it did not. Seemingly small, referring to the mainstream (read: white) as the normative is dangerous and it is violent. You seldom meet a Haitian person in the United States that does not know this. While anecdotal, I’ve heard several times from strangers, often when I point out Haitians’ contribution to the world, that you never meet a Haitian that won’t tell you about the history (and thereby present-day) of Haiti. It’s commonplace. Perhaps this was Ms. Porter’s experience, but to position it as the norm is to emphasize one’s own privilege and existence.
Suggesting they’ve broken a case in the “why” of Haiti’s poverty is excruciatingly oblivious and purposely naive.
It’s a fair point to make that many folks blame the poverty in Haiti on corruption amongst government officials. The reference in both the interview and the article requires more attention.
The thing about corruption is it seldom lives in a silo. There is an assumption that the corruption that exists in Haiti is shouldered by the Haitian government. It is. Though, it is encouraged and perpetuated by world powers, including the United States. The Times does mention the external participation in the ousting of Aristide. But it does not discuss the decades and decades of U.S. participation in Haitian politics, their support of the Duvalier dictatorship, their creation of puppet governments and the overall perpetuation of the idea that Haiti just can’t seem to get it together. The United States has groomed future “leaders” of Haiti and then wagged its finger at them once they’ve completed their bidding.
This superficial mention of corruption with little to no background, foundation and analysis leaves the reader believing that corruption is an open and closed case — that it is something that we can continue to blame.
I’m not a hater. I’m happy that the New York Times has presented this information to a different audience. I wrote my Master’s thesis about traditional and neo-colonial relationships with Haiti, much of which included the information shared in the article. I don’t believe many have two years to research and read about the history of Haiti, but I know that the information exists.
And this is the unfairness in their argument. The article perpetuates what people of color continue to fight against: white people saying something matters more than when Black people say it.
When it comes to international development work and its coverage, it’s an unfortunate commonplace. White privilege envelopes the researchers, writers and podcast hosts in a shroud of gold, their assertions are worthy of attention. And if they say it’s new information, then it must be.
The story is about access, white privilege and about the power to change a narrative when one feels like it. The article and the platform it appears on present a consistent, frightful juxtaposition: liberation can only be achieved should white people decide so. This information is deeply connected to liberation, as it can be monetized, celebrated and, in this case, believed. It disavows the homework assignments and the arguments over dinner and, what Haitians love the most, the political conversations over dominoes, fritay, at barbershops or during Sunday exchanges.
Pulitzer-prize winning journalist and Founder of The Haitian Times, Garry Pierre-Pierreresponded to the article thoughtfully, suggesting it doesn’t matter who gets the credit. I respectfully disagree. Though he did make me think twice.
The thing about The New York Times article is that it reinforces an uncomfortable truth: the only things that matter are the things that come out of the mouth of white people; Black history isn’t interesting or titillating or oppressive until white people say so. And when white people take credit for work that has already been done many times over, it continues this narrative that they are the intellect, the bringer of truths, the ones worthy of trust.
The New York Times says that this work hadn’t been done before, that the numbers were buried, that no one knows this history. The New York Times ignores the stories Haitians have been telling their children for generations; these sentences allude to an idea that the research hadn’t been done previously. It’s tacit erasure.
I wonder if the New York Times considered the Haitian academics. (A few contemporary ones were included in writing the article, while there were Haitians whose opinions were included.) Ms. Porter also made sure to point out that they used a number of Haitian and Haitian American translators on the ground in Haiti and Florida. The Haitian Times hosted the NYT authors on a panel on June 20, where I asked this question and another about the role of white privilege in their telling of Haiti’s story. Time ran out before it got to be answered.
The fact that one white woman, two white men and a woman from East Africa got to tell the story of Haiti as the experts is an indication of a racism that may never cease. Again, this is not hate. This is an observation of the systems that maintain oppression.
And that is my issue. White supremacy isn’t the authors’ fault, but they surely participate and benefit from it.
If you’re interested in sharing your opinion on any cultural, political or personal topic, create an account and check out our how-to post to learn more.
PORT-AU-PRINCE (Reuters) – Hundreds of Haitian children are taking refuge at a prestigious high school in Port-au-Prince after escaping gang violence in the town of Cite Soleil that killed some 400 people and destroyed hundreds of homes this month. At the sprawling campus of Institution Saint-Louis de Gonzague, which is currently empty for summer vacation, children ranging from teenagers to toddlers are sleeping in classrooms that are serving as improvised dormitories. "The kids need a lot of help," said Sister Rosemiline, a nun with religious community group Kizito Family, who said she stopped using her last name after taking her vows.
Helane Becker, Cowen Senior Research Analyst, sits down with Yahoo Finance Live to examine United and American Airlines' earning reports and what factors are impacting the airline industry the most.
Toddlers to teenagers are sleeping in school classrooms as around 300 people are reportedly killed.
One RPD officer was killed and another was wounded, along with a bystander, in an ambush on Bauman Street.
The 67-year-old woman was airlifted from Portland in the US to Chennai in India for surgery.
Houston police are investigating a possible hate crime after a Black family received racial threats and found tires slashed on […] The post Black family reports racist threats, slashed tires in mostly white Houston neighborhood appeared first on TheGrio.
Music mogul Master P sat down for an interview with CBS Mornings on Friday to open up about his daughter’s fatal drug overdose.
With North Korea and Iran introducing more capable and maneuverable missile systems, the United States should reexamine boost-phase intercept options for improving U.S. homeland missile defense.
Football mania reached a fever pitch in Singapore when English Premier League clubs Liverpool and Crystal Palace came for the Standard Chartered Singapore Trophy pre-season match in July 2022. Fans packed the hotels and sponsor events to catch a glimpse of their football heroes, and roared on their teams at the National Stadium, with the biggest crowd attendance at a sports event since the COVID-19 pandemic.
A West Virginia man charged last week with brutally beating his sister, who awoke from a two-year coma and named him as her assailant, has died, according to officials.
ReutersA 12-year-old girl has been praised for her courage after she trekked for more than a mile to seek help for her 4-year-old sister, despite also suffering stab wounds.Florida police said despite the youngster’s bravery, her younger sister died from her injuries early Thursday morning.The stabbing, which occurred at a home in an Orlando suburb, was labeled a “domestic incident” by Sgt. Derek Chenoweth of the Longwood Police Department. In addition to the siblings, their 39-year-old father,
January 6 hearing days correspond to spikes in conspiracy theories on Telegram, Gab, 4Chan, and other 'niche' sites, experts say.
Cooper Roberts, 8, was able to go outside in a wheelchair and eat a popsicle, the first time since being paralyzed in the Highland Park shooting.
The employee had worked at Silver Dollar City since 2017.
A small plane crashed into the ocean near the Huntington Beach pier Friday afternoon and was caught on tape.
Photographs taken at a parade in Kajang, Malaysia, show an older man hugging and holding up his nephew, who had fainted after feeling unwell. The photographs, uploaded to Facebook by the Domestic Trade and Consumer Affairs Minister Alexander Nanta Linggi, went viral as many online users’ hearts were melted by the uncle’s compassion and love for his nephew. Nik Mohamad Aadhar Nik Ismadi, a police officer in Sabah, Malaysia, was standing in formation during an enforcer parade at the Maktab Penjara Kajang in Malaysia.
Fiji Broadcasting Corporation via VimeoAfter allegedly bludgeoning his wife and leaving her for dead on the bathroom floor of their luxury Fiji hotel room, Bradley Robert Dawson apparently thought it best to flee in a kayak.However, police found him three days later on nearby Matacawalevu Island, where a local said he came to in an effort to escape from an argument with his wife Christe Chen Dawson, 39, the local witness told the Daily Mail.Dawson, 38, from Tennessee, is now locked away in a Fij
Rescue crews feared the sinkhole would collapse further, reports said.
An attorney for a woman who contends Sesame Place character snubbed her daughter and niece says new video supports allegations it was intentional.
Men and women from two families brawled at Florida's Disney World. One person was hospitalized, and three were arrested, said the Orange County Sheriff's Office, Orlando.


What's your reaction?

In Love
Not Sure

You may also like

More in:Diaspora

Comments are closed.